5 Responses to “Is Adoption Voluntary?”

1. Ol Cranky Writes:
   March 3rd, 2005 at 4:52 pm

   Isn’t being raised by your biological parents also a decision that is imposed on children? Geez, I guess the only way not to selfishly impose your will on a child you might conceive is to get sterilized to ensure you never procreate - but then, you’re imposing your will on a child by not letting it get conceived. Hmmmmmmmmm

   This comment was written by Ol Cranky.
   Report this comment to the moderators
   
2. Bastardette Writes:
   April 5th, 2005 at 11:19 am

   Voluntary adoption is quite a loaded phrase. It is used by anti-adoptee oranizations such as the National Council for Adoption, various “pro-lilfe” organizations (NRTL, ALL) various “pro-choice” organizations, (NARAL, Planned Parenthood) , ACLU, Baby Safe Haven Yes, etc. Adoptees are, as you see, equally feared and hated across the political spectrum in order to keep adoption records and identities sealed from adopted adults–and to maintain a web of family secrets, lies, and abuses.

   These organizations like to claim that women “voluntarily” relinquished their children–I guess it makes them feel good about themselves– but the vast majority of birth mothers also say that they “volunteered” under extreme pressure, ie. there was no real choice involved. Pressued by parents, schools, social workers, churches they were often threatened with being kicked out of the house, out of school, loss of wages–and, of course, loss of reputation. The single most important factor traditionally has certainly been lack of parental support aka don’t you dare bring that little bastard home with you. Many birth mothers report that they were lied to by social workers who claimed that when their child turned 18 (or 21) that records would be open or that they would be reunited. That lie was the only thing that made the “voluntary” relinquishment acceptable.

   Adoption is generally a white middle class intra-class practice rooted in shame: shame of non-marital pregnancy, shame of bastardy, and shame of infertility–all of which props up a decaying Culture of Lies that creates an unholly alliance between dysfunctional famly pratices and the state which reassigns identity via adoption to “normalize” bourgeois family values.

   Where there is no real choice there is no real “voluntary” decisions.

   This comment was written by Bastardette.
   Report this comment to the moderators
   
3. Lubbuck Writes:
   April 5th, 2005 at 2:24 pm

   Maybe adoption wasn’t such a good idea, after all. Maybe orphanages were better. At least they were truthful. Adoption is just lie heaped on lie. Truth is better.

   This comment was written by Lubbuck.
   Report this comment to the moderators
   
4. Elena Writes:
   April 5th, 2005 at 2:46 pm

   There seem to be many circumstances that lead to adoption, and of course there is something wonderful about some adoptive familes. But I can definitely see where Bastardette is coming from. I know quite a few familes made up from adoption, some in my own extended family. Based on their experiences, my perspective of adoption is very positive. But I know only one birth mother, and her story gave me the creeps. My sister’s college roommate, from a white upper middle class family, forced her, there is no other word, to give away her baby. They probably told themselves that it was best to be in a two parent home, but I have a daughter and I would never, under any circumstances, be ok with her giving away her child, my grandchild. Would I be wrong? Maybe, but right now the very idea upsets me, and that girl’s parents seem…heartless. I hope noone takes offense, I just wanted to comment on this very complicated topic.

   This comment was written by Elena.
   Report this comment to the moderators
   
5. Kimberly Martinez Writes:
   September 10th, 2005 at 1:35 am

   When you are under age, and fighting to keep your very wanted much loved child to have them stolen away, it’s no choice.

   Boggles the mind to think that the stories of ladies from an older generation are still being relived today. Laws have changed but doesn’t mean practices have.

   I’m not saying that there aren’t those few that really didn’t want their child, but most do.

   I am a 32 year old mother of 5. My first child was born when I was 13.

   I was not found unfit by the hospital’s social workers, or by any state agency. I was kicked out of the house before I had even left the hospital. This was after being forced to stay 3 extra days in the hospital. The concept was to allow the social workers time to talk me out of my child.

   I bounced from a cousin’s house back to my mother’s. Any time I showed the pride and love I felt for my child, I was shamed by my mother. So many really stupid and selfish things reasons were given for why I should have been ashamed of her.

   To this day I am proud that I had her. For those who called her a bastard, I pitty them. It was because of her birth that I changed the person I was. It was for her that I broke 9 years of abuse. It was in her as I layed in bed watching her hick-up in my stomach that I finally found unconditional love.

   I fought for her and managed to keep her with me for 7 months. In the end I ran away when the adoption papers came in the mail. It was the only way I could think of to continue protesting her adoption.

   There was no choice. Now I have to look forward to possible rejection. Ialso know she may be fearing rejection too.

   The one thing I am sorry for, was not knowing my rights and local laws.

   This comment was written by Kimberly Martinez.
   Report this comment to the moderators
   

Leave a Reply

If you have questions about the moderation policies here, please read this post. Short version: treat other posters with respect.

If your submitted comment fails to appear, without even an error or "waiting for moderation" message, then our spam-blocking software may have blocked your comment. Please contact the moderators immediately so we can rescue your comment. If this happens repeatedly, you might visit Akismet's comment form to tell them they're falsely identifying you as a spammer.